Tribe offers State of Arizona fallow deal worth $37.5m

The Colorado River Indian Tribes (CRIT) has offered the State of Arizona a deal in which they would agree to fallow enough land to save a total of 150,000 acre-feet of water in exchange for $37.5 million over 3 years.

With water levels continuing to drop toward a ‘shortage’ declaration at Lake Mead, the state has been meeting with stakeholders for months to forge a Drought Contingency Plan (DCP).

The offer, outlined in a November 9th letter to the Arizona Department of Water Resources and the Central Arizona Conservation District, would extend CRIT’s existing water fallowing agreements. CRIT would agree to set aside enough land to allow the state to save an additional 50,000 acre-feet of water per year, starting in January 2020. CRIT would get $250 per acre-foot.

The water would be stored in Lake Mead to help the state adopt the DCP, which has been developed by all the Colorado River Basin States in cooperation with Mexico to prevent the reservoirs Lake Mead and Lake Powell from dropping to such low levels that delivery of the water supply and power production are threatened. 50,000 acre-feet of water is enough to supply approximately 100,000 households for one year.

CRIT Chairman Dennis Patch said the Tribe has been working with the state for two years on solutions to the southwest water crisis.

“The proposal we delivered today puts real numbers to that offer that are significant to getting the necessary approvals for DCP,” he said in a statement.

The statement said:

“CRIT has the ability to assist Arizona because of its hard fought water rights to Colorado River water and its ability to fallow farm land when needed. CRIT holds the largest first priority water rights in Arizona for the use of Colorado River water. The proposal seeks $250 for each acre-foot. The CRIT offer would not diminish Central Arizona Project supplies nor any other available water supplies in central Arizona.

 The agreement would also generate new revenues the Tribal Council could use for key tribal programs and services.”

CRIT Vice-Chairman Keith Moses said $250 is a low value for its water, but the Tribe wishes to be part of the solution.

“We know our water is worth more than $250 an acre-foot,” he said. “We are making this proposal at this price for the benefit of the River and to move the process forward in Arizona for approval of the Drought Contingency Plan.”

A smaller agreement is already in place. Since 2016, CRIT has been making water available for system conservation under the Reclamation-sponsored pilot program. The new proposal would use the same methods and build upon the success of the pilot program.

The water fallowing program is not the same as water leasing, which CRIT would also like to do, with authorization from Congress.

“The Tribal Council believes the greater value for water users in Arizona will come with Congressional authorization to make a portion of CRIT’s Colorado River allocation available for off-reservation use in Arizona while still preserving CRIT’s first priority rights.”

CRIT voters will decide whether to lease its water in this way in a referendum to be held in mid-January.

8 comments

  1. That offer is good and thank you cRIT for everything you are doing to help Arizona. Water flows and flows and there is no loss for CRIT only a gain for everyone becase CRIT will get much needed money for the people and the state will get more water.

  2. Tim Mariscal

    Really 37.5 million over 3 yrs? 🤦🏻‍♂️

  3. Angela Salazar

    That’s 12.5 million per year…

  4. What is the difference between what the fallowed land would earn, and the $37 Million dollars?
    How will this affect farm employment? Will it force lay-offs and/or firing of farm employees?
    Will they force leasehold farms to fallow their land, or just apply this to CRIT owned farms?
    What will the $37 Million be applied to? “…new revenues the Tribal Council could use for key tribal programs and services” is a pretty vague statement.

  5. Alicia Wilson-Croteau

    Don’t know enough about to be for or against, but at least some are willing to try to plan ahead. I lived in Bullhead City when the Colorado River was dry, and don’t want to live through another one!

  6. The BIA is returning about 1,000-acre feet of excess water to the river each day. Why didn’t the Tribal Council sell this water that is being returned to the river? It’s excess water BIA diverted from the river but wasn’t used, plus seepage from irrigated farm land. The kicker is that CRIT doesn’t get credit for the water returned.
    Some of the land that is being fallowed could be leased for $200 an acre. Then the Tribes would be getting $250 from the return flow to the river and another $200 from the acreage that is being fallowed. The return flow to the river is over 200,000-acre feet plus per year. Now if our Tribal Council would have sold 200,000-acre feet at $250 an acre foot, we would be receiving $50,000,000 (million) a year. Check my math.
    The return flows are measured in real-time so rather than a set amount, a percentage of whatever is being retuned could be sold. If something catastrophic happened and there weren’t any return flows, they would get a percentage of nothing. In the present agreements, our “Perfected Water Rights” are mentioned and this could set a precedent.
    Using Bureau of Reclamation’s Evaporation Transpiration (ET) data (10-acre feet per acre), CRIT would need to fallow 5,000 acres. If the Tribes leased the 5,000 acres of fallowed land for $200 an acre, it would bring in $1,000,000.
    On irrigated farm land, even when fallowed, the Tribes will have to pay BIA Irrigation O&M fees of $54 an acre per year which would be $270, 000 per year.
    When you mess with our land and water, you better know what you’re doing. Some people can’t walk from one side of a corral to the other without getting their feet wet.

  7. But what citizens wouldnot be Concerned regarding the leaders using water for extreme puroposes?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *